A modern history of literacy education

The search for best method

The second section on the assembled reader and the “Search for Best       Method” followed a period of intensity spurred by concern that reading failures were growing and a belief that researchers should identify the best method for teaching beginning reading. It was as if there was a race between approaches in hopes of a   “silver bullet”.  The race was wrought with difficulties and problems that provided more questions than answers. In terms of readers, it is a period when reading development involved a scope and sequence of skills as if readers could be assembled.

The Assembled Reader

In the 1960s there was a growing interest in developing detailed systems for education. This was in part fueled by research that speculated about components that might be sequenced and mastered sequentially in order for one to learn. These systems drew their rationale from theories of learning (e.g., Gagné, 1965: Bloom, 1968) that featured optimal and/or typical sequences of skill acquisition and assessments designed to measure each step along the way. Reading was not spared this approach, as developmental approaches shifted to those that reconfigured learning as more akin to an assembly line (Guthrie, 1973). This approach did not appear overnight; to the contrary, there was a long tradition of separate, decontextualized skill instruction dating back to at least the 1930s and perhaps to the founding era of the field of educational psychology in the very early years of the Twentieth Century. ...

The Search for Best Method

In the 1960s, standard curriculum remained dominated by approaches to skill development that involved a diet of graded reading materials tied to a scope and sequence of skills to be mastered across the grades. The approach to reading research remained heavily influenced by psychologists who used various tests to explore the relationship between variables and overall reading achievement. Indeed, a testing regimen increasingly dominated research, resulting in correlational studies, studies exploring aspects of reading difficulties, and research and development on curriculum (including comparisons of different approaches to beginning reading that relied on test scores or testimonies to assess respective merits). ...

Accompanying Videos

Tierney-Pearson Conversion Series

Rob Tierney and P. David Pearson have a conversation about the issues on this topic.